Bladder neoplasms after nephroureterectomy: does the surgery of the lower ureter, transurethral resection or open surgery, influence the evolution?

Abstract

Nephroureterectomy is the treatment of choice for tumors of the upper urinary tract (UUTT). In 1952, a modified version of this technique was described, involving endoscopic detachment of the ureter followed by nephroureterectomy with a single lumbar incision. We reviewed a retrospective survey to assess whether UUTT patients treated with nephroureterectomy with no prior history of bladder tumor had different rates of incidence or different sites of bladder recurrence according to the specific technique employed. Patients were divided into group A, 87 patients who underwent a double incision nephroureterectomy and group B with 58 patients with prior detachment of the ureter. In both groups, incidence was calculated for two variables (bladder tumor recurrences and homolaterality of such recurrences) and chi-square tested. Bladder tumor was diagnosed at follow-up in 39% of patients in group A and 34.5% in group B, with no statistically significant difference (N.S.). Bladder tumor recurrences were homolateral to UUTT in 50% of group A cases and 55% of group B cases (N.S.). Although this is a retrospective survey of two asynchronous groups, given the similar nature of the UUTT cases in both groups and the fact that no statistically significant differences have been found, it is reasonable to conclude that nephroureterectomy with prior endoscopic detachment of the ureter is a safe and radical procedure.