Surgical treatment for non-union of the mid-shaft clavicle using a reconstruction plate: scapular malposition is related to poor results.

Abstract

A retrospective study was performed to evaluate the use of an AO reconstruction plate in open reduction and internal fixation for non-union of the mid-shaft clavicle, examining the relationship between the position of the scapula and final functional results and whether perioperative variables such as clavicular reconstruction ratio and period of non-union influence the position of the scapula. From January 1998 to January 2005, data on 21 people with symptomatic non-union of the mid-shaft clavicle were collected; 17 non-unions were atrophic and 4 were hypertrophic. Initially, treatment was conservative with a figure-of-eight bandage in 19 cases, and cerclage wire fixation in 2 cases. The follow-up period was 65.7 (24-108) months. Outcome analyses included standard clinical follow-up, plain radiography, the Constant-Murley scoring and subjective assessment. All non-unions united well in 13.6 (11-27) weeks. All patients were satisfied with their surgical results. Greater age and longer period of non-union resulted in a larger amount of scapular malposition, which related to poor functional results.