Biomechanical evaluation of two innovative locking implants for comminuted olecranon fractures under high-cycle loading conditions.

Abstract

The relatively high complication rate after fixation of olecranon fractures has led to an increasing application of anatomically pre-contoured locking plate systems. The purpose of the present study was to conduct a biomechanical comparison of olecranon osteosyntheses by applying the Olecranon VA-LCP and the 3.5mm LCP Hook Plate (LCP, locking compression plate) to an unstable fracture model under high-cycle loading conditions. After creating an unstable fracture (Schatzker type B), osteosynthesis was performed on eight pairs of fresh-frozen cadaveric ulnae by application of either the Olecranon VA-LCP (Synthes, Solothurn, Switzerland) or the 3.5mm LCP Hook Plate (Synthes, Solothurn, Switzerland). Loading (50,000 alternating loads, cyclic and sinusoidal 10-300 N) was conducted by application of tensile load with the elbow in 90° flexion to simulate the tensile strength of the triceps brachii. For statistical analysis, angular displacement in the region of the humeral trochlea was taken as a measure of olecranon dislocation. In Group 1 (Olecranon VA-LCP), a median angular displacement of 0.36° (minimum 0.10°; maximum 0.80°) was observed after 500 alternating loads. In Group 2 (3.5-mm LCP Hook Plate), the medial displacement was 0.80° (minimum 0.13°; maximum 2.72°). The difference was nonsignificant (p = 0.128). The mean value for angular displacement in Group 1 after 50,000 cycles was 0.80° (minimum 0.31°; maximum 1.99°), whereas in Group 2 a mean angular displacement of 2.02° (minimum 0.71°; maximum 6.40°) was recorded. The difference was statistically significant (p = 0.017). In Group 2, implant failure in the form of proximal plate pullout occurred in one construct after 756 cycles. A significantly higher biomechanical stability can be achieved in the fixation of unstable olecranon fractures by application of the Olecranon VA-LCP rather than the 3.5mm LCP Hook Plate.