Nuclear genomes distinguish cryptic species suggested by their DNA barcodes and ecology.

Abstract

DNA sequencing brings another dimension to exploration of biodiversity, and large-scale mitochondrial DNA cytochrome oxidase I barcoding has exposed many potential new cryptic species. Here, we add complete nuclear genome sequencing to DNA barcoding, ecological distribution, natural history, and subtleties of adult color pattern and size to show that a widespread neotropical skipper butterfly known as <i>Udranomia kikkawai</i> (Weeks) comprises three different species in Costa Rica. Full-length barcodes obtained from all three century-old Venezuelan syntypes of <i>U. kikkawai</i> show that it is a rainforest species occurring from Costa Rica to Brazil. The two new species are <i>Udranomia sallydaleyae</i> Burns, a dry forest denizen occurring from Costa Rica to Mexico, and <i>Udranomia tomdaleyi</i> Burns, which occupies the junction between the rainforest and dry forest and currently is known only from Costa Rica. Whereas the three species are cryptic, differing but slightly in appearance, their complete nuclear genomes totaling 15 million aligned positions reveal significant differences consistent with their 0.00065-Mbp (million base pair) mitochondrial barcodes and their ecological diversification. DNA barcoding of tropical insects reared by a massive inventory suggests that the presence of cryptic species is a widespread phenomenon and that further studies will substantially increase current estimates of insect species richness.