Editorial Commentary: Polyurethane Meniscal Scaffold: A Perfect Fit or Flop?

Abstract

The goal of using a synthetic scaffold to establish a biomechanically functioning meniscus or provide an equivalent meniscus substitute is not achieved by the polycaprolactone-polyurethane Actifit scaffold. Recent research, that did not include a control group, shows that the revision rate is significant, and any improvements in patient outcomes could reflect the associated reconstructive surgery. Based on these data and similar published reports, it is premature to conclude that this implant is clinically indicated. The technique is currently more flop than fit.