Correlation between NDI, PROMIS and SF-12 in cervical spine surgery.

Abstract

As the focus in spine surgery has shifted from radiographic to patient-centric outcome, patient-reported outcomes measures (PROMs) are becoming increasingly important. They are linked to patient satisfaction, and are used to assess healthcare expenditure, determine compensation and evaluate cost-effectiveness. Thus, PROMs are important to various stakeholders, including patients, physicians, payers, and healthcare institutions. Thus, it is vital to establish methods to interpret and evaluate these outcome measures. To evaluate the correlation between Neck Disability Index (NDI), Patient Reported Outcome Measurement Information System Physical Function (PROMIS-PF) and Short Form-12 Physical Health Score (SF-12 PHS) in cervical spinal surgery in order to determine the validity of PROMIS-PF in these patients. Retrospective review of prospectively collected data. Consecutive patients who underwent cervical surgery for degenerative spinal pathology with a minimum of 3 months follow-up. Self-reported measures that is, PROMs including NDI, PROMIS-PF, and SF-12 PHS. No funding was received for this study. The authors report no relevant conflict of interest. PROM collected preoperatively and at each follow-up were analyzed using Pearson product-moment correlation. Of the 121 patients included, 66 underwent anterior cervical discectomy and fusion, 42 cervical disc replacement, 13 posterior cervical decompression with or without fusion. A statistically significant improvement was achieved in all PROMs by 6 weeks and maintained at 1 year. Furthermore, the percentage of patients achieving an improvement greater than minimum clinically important difference was similar for NDI and PROMIS-PF, particularly at a follow-up of 3 months or more. A statistically significant negative correlation was seen between NDI and PROMIS-PF, which was moderate preoperatively and in the early postoperative period (r=-0.565 to -0.600), and strong at 3 months or longer follow-up (r=-0.622 to -0.705). A statistically significant, negative correlation was also seen between SF-12 PHS and NDI, which was moderate preoperatively and at 6 weeks (r=-0.5551 to -0.566); and strong at all other time-points (r=-0.678 to -0.749). There was a statistically significant positive correlation between SF-12 PHS and PROMIS-PF, which was strong to very-strong at all time-points (r=0.644-0.822), except at 2 weeks (r=0.570). Although NDI and SF-12 have been used for several years, PROMIS is a new outcome measure that is increasingly being implemented. The results of our study demonstrate the convergent and discriminant validity of PROMIS-PF, supported by the strong correlation between SF-12 PHS and PROMIS-PF at all time-points and the moderate correlation between NDI and PROMIS-PF preoperatively and in the early postoperative period, respectively. Thus, while PROMIS-PF may not be a good surrogate for disease-specific outcome measures, it may extend value as a precise and efficient general health tool.