Patient perceptions on mesh use in hernia repair: A prospective, questionnaire-based study.

Abstract

There has been increasing media coverage regarding the controversy of using mesh in various operations. At this time, there are no published studies evaluating the potential influence of this controversy on patients' perceptions. Therefore, our study aimed to assess patient perceptions of hernia repair surgery with mesh as well as factors that may influence patient opinions. A 16-item questionnaire evaluated each patient's perceptions of the use of mesh in their upcoming hernia repair. The primary outcomes of interest were their level of comfort regarding the possibility of hernia repair surgery with mesh, aversion to hernia surgery with mesh, and positive belief that mesh is a safe product in hernia repair surgery. We included 100 patients presenting for a hernia repair and 100 patients presenting for other operations. Both groups identified the media as their most common influence (37% and 40%, respectively). Factors leading to a high level of comfort regarding the possibility of mesh repair included believing mesh was a safe product (P < .001) and hearing about the advantages of mesh (P = .012) from medical professionals (P = .001). Factors leading to a positive belief that mesh was a safe product included the male sex (P = .015), a high socioeconomic standing (P = .006), and their own personal experience (P = .013). Factors leading to aversion to mesh use included the female sex (P = .006) and hearing about meshes causing mesh-related (P = .028) and wound-related complications (P = .025) as well as chronic pain (.008). Despite the high penetration of non-medical information in the population before presentation for medical care, most patients overall do not seem to be opposed to the concept of the use of mesh in a hernia repair, but there are certain factors associated with aversion to the use of mesh that physicians should acknowledge and should address this potential issue.