Editorial Commentary: Operative Versus Nonoperative Management of Shoulder Instability in the National Football League Athlete: Do What Needs to Be Done-Treatment Choice Does Not Affect Future Performance or Games Played.

Abstract

Shoulder instability is common in the National Football League athlete. Nonoperative versus operative treatment of shoulder labrum injury without bone loss depends on many factors, including type and direction of instability, presence or absence of pain and recurrent instability that limits function, and player and season situational issues. Prophylactic surgical treatment in an effort to enhance future player performance and increase the number of future games played should be discouraged. Management of shoulder instability should be based on clinical indication and surgical stabilization should not be done prophylactically in the hope of increasing the number of future games played or enhancing performance.