The microbiological and physical properties of catheters for intermittent catheterization: a systematic review on the impact of reuse and cleaning.

Abstract

Systematic Review. To review systematically the clinical evidence of the effectiveness of various intermittent catheter cleaning methods that have been proposed as methods to prepare catheters for reuse. A keyword search in Medline, Excerpta Medica dataBASE, the Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature, Web of Science and Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, was undertaken to identify all English, Russian and German language literature evaluating the effectiveness of various intermittent catheter cleaning methods. Studies selected for review included analytical experimental, prospective cohort and cross-sectional. Cleaning methods reviewed included heat-based sterilization, chemical cleaning solutions, mechanical abrasion, photocatalytic sterilization, and combined methods. Overall, 12 studies were included. Heat-based sterilization and mechanical abrasion methods were either not effective or damaged the physical properties of catheters. Two studies reported evidence that their chemical cleaning methods (i.e., soaked catheters in a 70% alcohol solution for 5 min or combined approach detergent wash followed by soaking in Milton sterilizing fluid also known as the Milton method) both preserved the structural integrity of their catheters and were bactericidal. Numerous cleaning methods resulted in the destruction of catheters. However, there are two reported cleaning methods, submersion for 5 min in 70% alcohol and the "Milton method", that eliminate bacterial colonization while leaving the physical properties of the catheters unchanged. While these cleaning methods are promising, each was published in just one study, therefore higher-powered / longitudinal studies confirming the safety and efficacy of these cleaning methods must be obtained before current clinical recommendations can be modified.