Comment on "Discovery of davemaoite, CaSiO<sub>3</sub>-perovskite, as a mineral from the lower mantle".

Walter, Michael J; Kohn, Simon C; Pearson, D Graham; Shirey, Steven B; Speich, Laura; Stachel, Thomas; Thomson, Andrew R; Yang, Jing · Science · 2022

editorial · Level V

Where this comes from

Abstract

Tschauner <i>et al</i>. (Reports, 11 November 2021, p. 891) present evidence that diamond GRR-1507 formed in the lower mantle. Instead, the data support a much shallower origin in cold, subcratonic lithospheric mantle. X-ray diffraction data are well matched to phases common in microinclusion-bearing lithospheric diamonds. The calculated bulk inclusion composition is too imprecise to uniquely confirm CaSiO<sub>3</sub> stoichiometry and is equally consistent with inclusions observed in other lithospheric diamonds.