Response to Comment on "The early origin of a birdlike inner ear and the evolution of dinosaurian movement and vocalization".

Abstract

David <i>et al</i>. claim that vestibular shape does not reflect function and that we did not use phylogenetic inference methods in our primary analyses. We show that their claims are countered by comparative and direct experimental evidence from across Vertebrata and that their models are empirically unverified. We did use phylogenetic methods to test our hypotheses. Moreover, their phylogenetic correction attempts are methodologically inappropriate.