Venus water loss is dominated by HCO<sup>+</sup> dissociative recombination.

Chaffin, M S; Cangi, E M; Gregory, B S; Yelle, R V; Deighan, J; Elliott, R D; Gröller, H · Nature · 2024

basic_science · Level V

Where this comes from

Abstract

Despite its Earth-like size and source material<sup>1,2</sup>, Venus is extremely dry<sup>3,4</sup>, indicating near-total water loss to space by means of hydrogen outflow from an ancient, steam-dominated atmosphere<sup>5,6</sup>. Such hydrodynamic escape likely removed most of an initial Earth-like 3-km global equivalent layer (GEL) of water but cannot deplete the atmosphere to the observed 3-cm GEL because it shuts down below about 10-100 m GEL<sup>5,7</sup>. To complete Venus water loss, and to produce the observed bulk atmospheric enrichment in deuterium of about 120 times Earth<sup>8,9</sup>, nonthermal H escape mechanisms still operating today are required<sup>10,11</sup>. Early studies identified these as resonant charge exchange<sup>12-14</sup>, hot oxygen impact<sup>15,16</sup> and ion outflow<sup>17,18</sup>, establishing a consensus view of H escape<sup>10,19</sup> that has since received only minimal updates<sup>20</sup>. Here we show that this consensus omits the most important present-day H loss process, HCO<sup>+</sup> dissociative recombination. This process nearly doubles the Venus H escape rate and, consequently, doubles the amount of present-day volcanic water outgassing and/or impactor infall required to maintain a steady-state atmospheric water abundance. These higher loss rates resolve long-standing difficulties in simultaneously explaining the measured abundance and isotope ratio of Venusian water<sup>21,22</sup> and would enable faster desiccation in the wake of speculative late ocean scenarios<sup>23</sup>. Design limitations prevented past Venus missions from measuring both HCO<sup>+</sup> and the escaping hydrogen produced by its recombination; future spacecraft measurements are imperative.