Preoperative planning in orthopaedic trauma surgery: a lost art?

Abstract

Preoperative planning is a helpful tool for orthopaedic trauma cases, but clinical experience dictates that its use remains inconsistent. The primary aim of this cross-sectional survey study was to investigate practices and applications of preoperative planning for orthopaedic trauma cases and to identify factors influencing its use. A cross-sectional 26-item survey was distributed to members of the Orthopaedic Trauma Association and The Netherlands Orthopaedic Trauma Association between April 2024 and August 2024. Four key areas of interest were assessed: (1) general preoperative planning practices; (2) features of the preoperative plan; (3) use of preoperative planning for resident training; and (4) factors influencing the decision to make a preoperative plan. General preoperative planning practices were compared between attendings and residents or fellows. Two-hundred-eleven orthopaedic surgeons, fellows, or residents completed the survey (84 % male, 74 % attending, 55 % of attendings trauma-fellowship-trained). Overall, 84 % of respondents considered preoperative planning very or extremely important. Formal preoperative planning was performed on average for 50 % of cases. Residents or fellows planned significantly more often than attendings (76 % vs. 30 %, p < 0.001) and used digital templating more often (59 % vs. 38 %, p= 0.006). The most common features of the plan were tactical, including positioning of implants and specific steps of approach and reduction. Residents reported that preoperative plans were discussed preoperatively in 75 % of cases and postoperatively evaluated in 40 %. Case complexity was the most influential factor in deciding to plan. Respondents considered preoperative planning to be very or extremely important for orthopaedic trauma cases but made a formal preoperative plan on average in only half of cases. Residents or fellows made a preoperative plan twice as often. Complexity of the case was the most important factor in deciding to make a preoperative plan. Benefits of preoperative planning such as improving resident teaching and learning, efficiency, and teamwork should be considered more often in the decision to make a preoperative plan.