Isotope-Labeled Graphene Reveals the Extrinsic Origin of Raman Signatures Assigned to Graphene Edge Modes.

Surange, Uttung; Lemelin, Vincent; Bourbonnais-Sureault, David; Aygar, Ayse Melis; Martel, Richard; Szkopek, Thomas · ACS Nano · 2026

basic_science · Level V

Where this comes from

Abstract

Sharp Raman bands near 1450 and 1530 cm<sup>-1</sup> observed under 633 nm excitation have previously been attributed to localized vibrational modes of zigzag and armchair graphene edges. Here, we employ an isotope-resolved Raman spectroscopy approach to investigate the origin of these features. Monolayer <sup>13</sup>C graphene was synthesized and transferred alongside <sup>12</sup>C graphene reference samples, enabling a direct comparison of isotope-dependent Raman signatures under identical processing conditions. Despite clear isotope-induced shifts of the intrinsic graphene modes, the peaks near 1450 and 1530 cm<sup>-1</sup> exhibit no isotope-dependent frequency shift, demonstrating that they do not originate from graphene lattice vibrations. Instead, their excitation-wavelength dependence and spectral characteristics are consistent with Raman enhancement of adsorbed molecular species under resonant conditions. These results establish isotope labeling as a robust experimental strategy for distinguishing intrinsic graphene vibrational modes from extrinsic Raman signals and provide a revised interpretation of Raman features previously attributed to graphene edge phonons.