No longer a nurse, still not a doctor.

Eckelbarger, Julie · Postgrad Med J · 2026

Where this comes from

Abstract

This reflective narrative explores an uncomfortable and unexpected encounter with a patient mistaking a young physician for a chaplain and asking her to pray. The essay reflects on themes of professional identity, communication, and the complexity of patient perception. The narrative uses humor and introspection to examine how physicians are seen in vulnerable moments and explores whether misidentification reflects a failure of clear communication or a deeper need of patients seeking comfort. Ultimately, the piece emphasizes the importance of presence, connection, and asks the reader to question their level of comfort (or discomfort) with misidentification in the healthcare environment.