Comparison of therapeutic efficacies of type A and F botulinum toxins for blepharospasm: a double-blind, controlled study.

Abstract

Type F botulinum toxin can be used for treating patients with dystonia who become refractory to type A toxin injection due to antibody development. We compared the therapeutic efficacy of type F botulinum toxin to that of type A toxin in a self-controlled, double-blind clinical trial. In nine patients with blepharospasm, we injected type A toxin on one side and the same units of type F toxin on the other side. Although the onset of clinical effect, maximal benefit, and adverse reactions were similar between type A and F toxins, the duration of the clinical effect was significantly shorter on the side injected with type F toxin. Although type F toxin proved its promise as an alternative to type A toxin, its usefulness is limited by the shorter duration of action.